View Full Version : Cardigan rib button holes

11-27-2006, 10:48 AM
Hello! I am new to the forum but have knitted a few things before. I am in the UK so I use the english knitting method.

I am just trying to finish a cardigan that I have been doing on and off for a few years.... :oops:

It is a Jaeger pattern (JH 0056) in Iona Tweed Aran and I am doing the ladies version. It's basically a stocking stitch pattern with large ribbing at all the edges. The problem I have is to do with the buttonholes on one long side. Consists of 7 rows of K2 P2 ribbing, with the buttonholes in the 4th row. The pattern goes like this:

Row 4: (RS), rib 3, yrn (to make buttonhole), K2tog, rib 6, yrn(buttonhole), K2tog, *rib 10, yrn, K2tog: rep eat form * 5 more times.

Now, having looked at the how to stuff on here I don't think that this a good buttonhole method, but that aside I think that I have not even done this properly. When I saw yrn, I brought the yarn around the needle so that it was in the Knit position but not wrapped around the needle to make an extra stitch. For the K2tog I did just that, put my needle through both stitches and knit them as if they were one.

With the ribbing finished (which was difficult because it went wrong, and now I see why as I actually lost stitches and messed up the rib rows), I find that I don't really have buttonholes at all, but one of two gappy bits (small and tight) and the others appear to be lost in the knitting.

Ok, do I have to unravel all the ribbing and start again? And will the buttonhole that they have in the pattern work if I do it properly?

Oh, and I am running horribly short of wool... :oops:

Thank you for any help!


11-27-2006, 12:33 PM
Hi Nicky! Welcome to the forum. That looks like the type of buttonhole that creates a small eyelet instead of a slit, which means that yes, the yrn should've created a new stitch. Have you tried putting a button through it, though? Maybe it'll work anyway. If it doesn't, from what I've read, that type of buttonhole isn't the sturdiest, but it works well for small buttons. HTH

11-27-2006, 12:48 PM

I'll examine it again to see if I can make it work for a small button: I don't relish the thought of having to undo it all. Only 7 rows but about 300 stitches!!

I'll let you know: thanks for the advice.

Nicky :frog: