KnittingHelp.com Forum

KnittingHelp.com Forum (http://www.knittinghelp.com/forum/index.php)
-   How-to Questions (http://www.knittinghelp.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=23)
-   -   3 needle bind off with just one set of "live stitches" still on the needle (http://www.knittinghelp.com/forum/showthread.php?t=113668)

KnitBeg 07-07-2013 09:10 AM

3 needle bind off with just one set of "live stitches" still on the needle
 
This summer I started a project to get rid of most of my left over wool. Usually this means that there is just a little from each color so I'm searching for "small things" to knit. I find that bracelets are very useful :p

There is thing which really stands out in the patterns I've seen - I haven't looked at knitting on a circular needle. So by using 'straight' needles I see that they often use the "3 needle bind off" to sew/knit the bracelets together so the knitwork becomes round. This seems such an elaborate thing to do, as the bracelets are usually just about 10 stitches wide so why go through the trouble of picking up stitches on the lower edge to use the 3-needle-bind-off-technique?!?
Or they mention the kitchiner stitch, but you'll need to pick up stitches too for that technique.

It really puzzles me. Isn't it way easier to just sew the sides together? When I sew, it looks the same as the picture I see here. I might see that the "3 needle bind off" is a bit faster when you have to put together a large number of stitches, but it seems such a hassle.

I know - where is the question in all this ;) Basically, I'd like to know what your choice would be to sew together a piece that is about 10 stitches wide and has only live stitches on one side of the project.

I guess am just looking for a reason to follow the instructions instead of avoiding the whole thing and using a button or a string. For I have to say, I never tried the 3-needle-bind-off-technique so far. I really dred the picking up of the stitches and the way it is going to look - being more comfortable with sewing the seam.

salmonmac 07-07-2013 10:18 AM

Three needle bind off is a sturdy, neat solution to joining two sets of live sts. Knitting even something as small as a bracelet, it's still useful because the seam lies flatter and is less obvious. Rather than pick up sts at the cast on edge, try a provisional cast on so that you have live sts there to join with the ending live sts. Using Kitchener will make an almost invisible join that's worth the extra time needed.
It's not so much that these techniques are faster but that they give a more finished look. Try out them out and you may find you like the results.

claireweber 07-07-2013 10:33 AM

I have not used the three needle bind-off technique although I do plan to use it on my WIP.

I have used a three needle technique for joining two knitted pieces together, producing a layered effect and I :heart: it. I :frog: the project a number of times, there were so many stitches, but once I got myself into a very focused place, I was successful. The join is beautiful! It is sturdy and appears seamless.

I think you would be very happy using the 3-needle bind off, it is worth the effort and you will have another technique to use in future projects.

GrumpyGramma 07-07-2013 11:59 AM

I'd use a provisional cast on as salmonmac suggests and then use it for the 3 needle BO. If you know you're going to use that BO there is no point in picking up stitches later to do it, it won't be as nice a finish.

Quote:

I have used a three needle technique for joining two knitted pieces together, producing a layered effect and I :heart: it.
Please, Claire, do tell us what this technique is.

claireweber 07-07-2013 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GrumpyGramma (Post 1380808)
I'd use a provisional cast on as salmonmac suggests and then use it for the 3 needle BO. If you know you're going to use that BO there is no point in picking up stitches later to do it, it won't be as nice a finish.



Please, Claire, do tell us what this technique is.


Since I haven't viewed many of the videos on this site :aww: it could be a technique that you all are familiar with.

It is like the three needle bind off only omitting the bind off part. I'm using it on my shawl for joining the knitted blocks together.

I knitted the bottom block of the back panel of my shawl and left it on a spare needle, finishing on a RS row. I then knitted a number of rows on the second block, ending on a RS row. Then with the wrong sides of both blocks facing up, and the first block on top, I joined both pieces, following the pattern for the second block, knitting one stitch from the first block together with one stitch from the second block.

GrumpyGramma 07-07-2013 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by claireweber (Post 1380821)
Since I haven't viewed many of the videos on this site :aww: it could be a technique that you all are familiar with.

It is like the three needle bind off only omitting the bind off part. I'm using it on my shawl for joining the knitted blocks together.

I knitted the bottom block of the back panel of my shawl and left it on a spare needle, finishing on a RS row. I then knitted a number of rows on the second block, ending on a RS row. Then with the wrong sides of both blocks facing up, and the first block on top, I joined both pieces, following the pattern for the second block, knitting one stitch from the first block together with one stitch from the second block.

I made a ruffled purse for my GD and did this, ending up with ruffles that overlapped the fabric I knitted underneath. I'm not seeing how it works for your shawl but that's OK. My brain is mush anyhow. :noway: Maybe a picture in What'cha Knittin'?

claireweber 07-07-2013 02:54 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by GrumpyGramma (Post 1380826)
I made a ruffled purse for my GD and did this, ending up with ruffles that overlapped the fabric I knitted underneath. I'm not seeing how it works for your shawl but that's OK. My brain is mush anyhow. :noway: Maybe a picture in What'cha Knittin'?

Mine is mush now, too. :whoosh: Just got a lesson from my DH in resizing and posting, so I'll see if I can post it here, just posted it on What'cha Knittin.

GrumpyGramma 07-07-2013 03:05 PM

Thanks so much, Claire, that is simply stunning. I'm sorry the posting was such a pain but at least you had quality time with your DH. :teehee: What'd he say when you were done, take 2 aspirin and call me in the morning? My DS will help me with things computer but he'd really rather not.

claireweber 07-07-2013 03:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GrumpyGramma (Post 1380832)
Thanks so much, Claire, that is simply stunning. I'm sorry the posting was such a pain but at least you had quality time with your DH. :teehee: What'd he say when you were done, take 2 aspirin and call me in the morning? My DS will help me with things computer but he'd really rather not.

He poured me a beer :clink: We do not lesson well, but we manage to make it through. My husband worked for many years in the field of computers, part of his job was instructing other employees. I can be proud to hold the nomenclature of perhaps his worst student ;)

KnitBeg 07-09-2013 07:55 AM

Thank you all for the replies. As for the 3 needle bind off - I guess I should just try ;)

I had never heard of a provisional cast on. I read and looked at some video's about it and I think that it will indeed be quite useful. :cheering: Thank you so much for bringing this to my attention.

However, I understand that this is a cast on techique. So it won't apply for the bracelets I already made which are waiting to be sewn/knit together so they can go around my wrist :p I guess I'll just have to be creative with those...

I'll be back to show what a finished product with this 3 needle bind off looks like.

BTW that shawl looks amazing and I can see how this technique is useful there (without having to pick up stitches).


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:40 AM.


copyright knittinghelp.com