Sugar & Cream and Peaches & Cream have about the same yardage, at least based on the dishcloths I've done. I prefer Peaches & Cream, but I've never used Shine.
Find me on Ravelry
On the Needles:
Monkey's in STR Titania
My So Called Scarf in Manos del Uruguay 115 (Flame)
Wonderful Wallaby in Berroco Ultra Alpaca
Dale of Norway Sheep Sweater