I like the chocolate idea even though I can't eat chocolate
I also like psammeadred idea of the teas. That was going to be my suggestion. National Wildlife store
has some nice sets of the BIG mugs $4.97 for a set of 4 + $4.99 shipping. I bought a few sets because I figured I could put 2 mugs and some tea and have several nice gifts handy for those unexpected oops I forgot to get gifts or for the mailman or other service people who I want to say an extra thanks to. They still had ones with wildflowers, seashells, or pinecones on them last I checked (most of the others are sold out).
Like Jane and others, I have my share of lotions and candles since it seems to be what everyone gives for housewarming gifts or when they don't know what else to give. I don't think I'll ever run out.