I thought your biggest problem would be finding the colors in Central New York - UNTIL I remembered that Syracuse University has navy and orange as their school colors. I bet this store in Syracuse http://www.theknittingconnection.net/
would know just what you need and just might have the colors in stock. Alternately, you could try some Chicago area stores' websites. Blue and Orange are complimentary colors - just about any striped scarf would look good with those colors.