Originally Posted by Cynamar
I know what I don't like--Bernat Softee Chunky! I bought four skeins the other day just for charity squares. It felt nice in the store. My square is like plastic.
Did you use an appropriate needle size? They recommend a 10, but if you knit at all tight you could go even higher. If the needle is too small the result won't be soft and floppy like knitting should be.
I find these all really soft. These are worsted weight since that is probably what you need for squares.
Caron Simply Soft
Red Heart SOFT (not supersaver)