So, it's
a sock

It's made with Cat's Sweet Tomato Heel but only two wedges instead of three. Plus, the yarn is a bit thicker than sock yarn so maybe the second pair with proper yarn would turn out better. Anyway, I feel somewhat accomplished today
Also, credit goes to Cindy for her help with making toe up socks! Thanks!
ETA: Please scroll down to see two pairs made a few days later!
