OK, it DOES work....but it seems that one side is looser and um...fluffier?
Is it normal for it to be nubbly one one side and not the other?
I have found the difference between my method and the other. For this thread's sake, it will be called the Double Loop CO. It creates a neater cast-on edge and looks like (similar to) a braid. Its also VERY VERY hard to make a nice loose row.
Well actually it looks like a series of 'v's. (<<<<<<<<<<<) And both sides are nubbly-free!