It does look like butter which is beautiful, unfortunately I can't wear yellows, oranges, or peaches and even green is iffy for me. My coloring just doesn't work with them. That was the first step in my decision making process. I really love blue, but then I thought I might want to wear my pretty shawl with jeans and I can be picky about the blues matching. I really wanted a color so that left me with the reds and purples and I chose the mulled wine because I think it is pretty. So, that was my decision making process!
I also went with the knit picks because I was already placing an order and got free shipping.
There is probably one color that is really just jumping out at you and you are liking...go for it!