Sorry, haven't seen either. Do you have to pick one sight unseen? Have you tried looking for them at your library? Or a local bookstore so you can at least see the different patterns so you can tell which one has more appeal for you? At least look them up at knitpicks and amazon - they usually have views of a few of the patterns - that could help you decide.
Mirl56 at Ravelry, too.
Learn from the mistakes of others. You canít live long enough to make them all yourself. Eleanor Roosevelt
Lady Feb Sweater
more shawlettes, socks