Originally Posted by suzeeq
You might be knitting between the 2 sts on the left needle instead of knitting into the first stitch. And unlike when you did the CO, leave the new st on the R needle and drop the old st off the L needle.
Thank you so much! That was exactly what I was doing.
A change in yarn and needle size later, I've got it down! Gosh. I don't know why that was so confusing. Seems none of the videos I watched got a clear view of that step.
Alright, off to see if I can do a 25 stitch row!